How to Write Volunteer Coordination Emails That Actually Get Responses

Our animal shelter had a volunteer problem. Not recruiting—we had plenty of sign-ups. The problem was nobody actually showed up.

Of every 10 people who signed up, 2 would complete their first shift. Of those 2, maybe 1 would come back.

After three months of changing our emails (and nothing else), our show rate jumped to 80% and retention hit 90%. Same people. Same shelter. Different communication.

Why Volunteers Ghost

Most volunteer coordinators assume ghosting is about commitment. People sign up emotionally and then reality hits.

That's part of it. But looking at our data, the bigger problem was confusion. Our volunteers didn't show up because they weren't sure:

• Where exactly to go
• What exactly to do
• Whether they were actually needed
• If they'd be in the way

Our emails were friendly and appreciative. They just weren't clear.

The Confirmation Email That Changed Everything

Our old confirmation email:

"Thank you so much for signing up to volunteer! We can't wait to see you on Saturday. Please arrive at the shelter and check in at the front desk. Let us know if you have any questions!"

Our new confirmation email:

"You're confirmed for Saturday, March 15 at 9am.

Where: Main shelter entrance, 123 Oak Street (not the clinic entrance). There's a volunteer parking area behind the building.

What you'll do: You'll be doing dog walking with Sarah, our volunteer coordinator. She'll meet you at the front desk at 9am and show you everything.

What to bring: Comfortable clothes you don't mind getting dirty, closed-toe shoes, a water bottle.

What to expect: Your first shift is 2 hours. You'll learn our dog handling basics and take 4-6 dogs for walks in the park across the street.

If something comes up: Text Sarah at (555) 123-4567. Seriously, it's no problem—just let her know.

See you Saturday!"

Same warmth. Way more clarity. Show rates doubled immediately.

The "What Will I Actually Do?" Problem

Most volunteer communications focus on why the cause matters. Which is important—but volunteers already know why the cause matters. That's why they signed up.

What they don't know is what they'll physically be doing.

Vague descriptions create anxiety:

• "Help at our community event" (Doing what exactly?)
• "Support our office team" (How?)
• "Make a difference" (Concretely how?)

Specific descriptions reduce anxiety:

• "Check people in at the registration table using our iPad system"
• "Organize donation boxes by size in our storage room"
• "Walk dogs from kennels to the outdoor play area"

When volunteers can picture themselves doing the task, they're more likely to show up.

The Reminder Sequence

One confirmation email isn't enough. People are busy. They forget.

Our reminder sequence:

• Confirmation email (immediately after signup)
• Week-before reminder (reiterates details, builds anticipation)
• Day-before text (simple: "See you tomorrow at 9am! Text me if anything comes up.")
• Morning-of text (for 10am+ shifts: "Looking forward to seeing you today!")

The day-before text was the biggest change. It gave people a face-saving way to bail ("something came up") instead of just ghosting. Surprisingly, most people who responded did show up—the text felt like a personal commitment.

The First-Shift Follow-Up

Your volunteer's first shift determines whether they become a regular.

Within 24 hours of their first shift, send a personal note:

"It was great meeting you yesterday! The dogs really enjoyed their walks—Max especially loved getting out. Would love to have you back next Saturday if you're interested. Same time works, or let me know what's better for your schedule."

Notice: specific detail from their shift, invitation to return, flexibility offered.

Generic "thanks for volunteering!" emails get ignored. Personal acknowledgment of what they actually did gets responses.

The Monthly Newsletter Problem

Most volunteer newsletters are organizational broadcasts: what's happening at the organization, upcoming events, donation drives.

Volunteers delete these immediately.

What works: volunteer-focused content.

• Spotlight on individual volunteers (everyone wants to see themselves)
• "You made this happen" stories (connecting their work to outcomes)
• Upcoming opportunities they specifically might enjoy
• Tips and skills related to their role

The ratio that works for us: 80% about volunteers and their impact, 20% organizational news.

Handling No-Shows Gracefully

Volunteers who ghost often feel too embarrassed to return. Your response to a no-show determines whether they come back.

Bad approach: "We noticed you missed your shift. Please let us know if you're still interested in volunteering."

Better approach: "Hi! Just checking in—hope everything's okay. We'd love to see you whenever you're available. No need to explain, just let me know when works for you."

This removes shame, keeps the door open, and actually gets people back.

The Scheduling Sweet Spot

Through trial and error, we learned:

Best signup timing: 3-7 days out. More than a week is too easy to forget. Less than 3 days feels last-minute.

Best shift lengths for new volunteers: 2-3 hours. Long enough to feel meaningful, short enough to not overwhelm.

Best first shift: Partnered with an experienced volunteer. Nobody wants to feel lost.

Best follow-up timing: Within 24 hours of their shift. Strike while the warm feelings are fresh.

Make It Easy to Say "Not This Time"

Counter-intuitive: the easier you make it to decline, the more people commit.

Every scheduling email should include a simple way to pass:

"If this weekend doesn't work, no problem at all—just hit reply and I'll remove you from this week. We'll have more opportunities next month."

This removes guilt about declining, which paradoxically increases commitment for people who do say yes.

The Investment Ladder

New volunteers shouldn't be asked for big commitments. Build investment gradually:

1. Single shift (try it out)
2. Monthly commitment (join the regulars)
3. Special roles (take on responsibility)
4. Leadership opportunities (train others)

Each step should feel like a natural progression, not a sales pitch.

---

Need help with clear, effective nonprofit communication? Try WriteBetter.ai to craft messages that inspire action.